Ethics of inclusion: Cultivate trust in precision medicine

Science
07 June 2019 Vol 364, Issue 6444
http://www.sciencemag.org/current.dtl

 

Policy Forum
Ethics of inclusion: Cultivate trust in precision medicine
By Sandra Soo-Jin Lee, Stephanie M. Fullerton, Aliya Saperstein, Janet K. Shim
Science07 Jun 2019 : 941-942 Restricted Access
We must explore how studies enhance diversity, inclusion
Summary
Precision medicine is at a crossroads. Progress toward its central goal, to address persistent health inequities, will depend on enrolling populations in research that have been historically underrepresented, thus eliminating longstanding exclusions from such research (1). Yet the history of ethical violations related to protocols for inclusion in biomedical research, as well as the continued misuse of research results (such as white nationalists looking to genetic ancestry to support claims of racial superiority), continue to engender mistrust among these populations (2). For precision medicine research (PMR) to achieve its goal, all people must believe that there is value in providing information about themselves and their families, and that their participation will translate into equitable distribution of benefits. This requires an ethics of inclusion that considers what constitutes inclusive practices in PMR, what goals and values are being furthered through efforts to enhance diversity, and who participates in adjudicating these questions. The early stages of PMR offer a critical window in which to intervene before research practices and their consequences become locked in (3).